32 Unique Thanksgiving Dishes

Thanksgiving is a day we take very seriously in my family. We have a long list of traditions, both old and newish. There has to be a morning activity, balloons are a must, board games make an appearance, and okay, there must be mashed potatoes and lots of them. 

unique thanksgiving dishes

While I take my Thanksgiving traditions very seriously, the menu is an area where I actually think we can all be a bit more flexible. Especially this year as we adjust to the idea of trading in our usual Thanksgiving plans for something smaller and more socially distant, there may be more reasons than ever to mix up the menu. Maybe you’ve reduced the guest list so much that a full turkey doesn’t make sense, maybe the star baker of the family (and sole owner of the secret pumpkin pie recipe) will be Zooming in, or maybe you just don’t like traditional Thanksgiving food and want this to be the year you stop pretending you do. If you want to bring more unique Thanksgiving dishes to the table, consider this your green light.

Think of a Thanksgiving table and you’re probably seeing the traditional players: turkey, stuffing, sweet potatoes topped with mini marshmallows, green bean casserole, pumpkin pie, mashed potatoes, canned cranberries, and pumpkin pie, to name a few. In contrast, take a play from Alison Roman who had this to say about her Thanksgiving menu:

“Of course I’ll be making turkey and gravy, to be eaten on a bed of stuffing (my favorite part). For the sides, I’ll make creamy potatoes, a sweet orange vegetable and a savory green vegetable. To provide a break from the richness, there’ll be cranberries on the table. For a bright, lemony moment, there’ll be herby salad to nibble on between bites of stuffing and gravy. To finish, I’m not a pumpkin person, so I’ll make an apple dessert to serve with lots of ice cream.”

Roman deconstructs the traditional suspects and rebuilds a Thanksgiving menu that fulfills a few general categories but suits her taste. For your table, pick at least one unique Thanksgiving recipe from each of the following categories.

Poultry with Gravy

Cozy Savory Side

Sweet Orange Vegetable

Savory Green Vegetable

Acidic Fruit Forward Side

Dessert That Screams Fall

Want more from aSweatLife? Get us in your inbox!

Eat Recipes

About Kira Schreiber

Kira grew up in the Chicago suburbs and is passionate about mental health, healthy eating, and sustainability. After spending the first part of her career working for a non profit mental health agency in Southern California, she transitioned to pursue a career in her passion for cooking. Now back in Chicago, Kira spends her days developing healthy recipes for a food tech start up. When not in the kitchen or on her laptop she loves spending time outdoors, hitting up a spin class, or watching home decor DIYs on YouTube.